5 Differences Between Vegetable Shortening vs Lard for Better Cooking Choices

Both professional chefs and home cooks know that cooking fat choice affects the flavor, texture, and health of dishes. Vegetable shortening and lard are common options with notable differences. This text explores their characteristics, health impacts, and disadvantages to guide you in choosing the right fat for your cooking needs.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!

What is Vegetable Shortening?

Vegetable shortening, introduced to consumers as Crisco in 1911, is a type of fat derived from plant oils like soybean, cottonseed, or palm. It’s a popular vegetarian alternative to animal-based fats such as butter or lard. The term ‘shortening’ comes from its ability to shorten or interrupt the gluten strands in baking, leading to a softer, more tender result – a quality highly sought after in pastries and other baked goods.

Vegetable shortening is 100% fat, making it high in calories but not containing any carbohydrates or protein. A tablespoon (12 grams) of Crisco All-Vegetable Shortening contains 110 calories, 12 grams of total fat, 3.5 grams of unsaturated fat, and 2.5 grams of saturated fat. It’s also worth noting that vegetable shortening does not require refrigeration and can last up to a year in an airtight container, making it a convenient option for many households.

What is Lard?

Lard, a cooking fat rendered from pork, has a long-standing history in culinary arts, particularly for producing tender, flaky pastries. Its distinctive flavor enriches traditional dishes, offering a nuanced alternative to vegetable shortening. Though marginally lower in saturated fat, lard provides a spectrum of vitamins and minerals absent in vegetable fats, thereby enhancing the nutritional profile of meals prepared with it.

Comparison of Health Benefits

Vegetable shortening is frequently promoted as a healthier choice than animal fats, given its reduced saturated fat content, which aids in managing cholesterol and diminishing heart disease risk. Additionally, it is usually devoid of trans fats that elevate harmful LDL cholesterol and lower beneficial HDL cholesterol. Nonetheless, it’s important to recognize that vegetable shortening is a processed food and should be consumed in moderation.

Lard, an animal fat, offers health benefits such as heart-friendly monounsaturated fats and vitamin D, supporting bone and immune health. Contrary to misconceptions, its cholesterol content is necessary for bodily functions. Moreover, lard is free from trans fats and hydrogenated oils due to minimal processing.

Saturated Fats and Cholesterol Levels

Saturated fats have been associated with an increase in total cholesterol levels, particularly LDL (low-density lipoprotein), often referred to as ‘bad’ cholesterol. A high level of LDL cholesterol can lead to plaque buildup in the arteries, which can increase the risk of heart disease and stroke. Vegetable shortening has less saturated fat than lard, but lard has more monounsaturated fats which can lower ‘bad’ LDL and raise ‘good’ HDL cholesterol. Thus, neither is clearly healthier than the other based on saturated fat alone.

Heart Health

Once considered heart-healthy due to less saturated fat, vegetable shortening has been scrutinized for producing trans fats through hydrogenation. Nowadays, though trans-fat free, the creation of spreadable shortening by interesterification could still risk health, potentially causing inflammation and affecting blood sugar regulation.

Contrary to popular belief, lard may not be as bad for your heart as previously thought. As mentioned earlier, lard contains a significant amount of monounsaturated fats, particularly oleic acid—the same type of fat found in olive oil. Monounsaturated fats are considered heart-healthy as they can help lower LDL cholesterol levels and increase HDL cholesterol levels. However, like all fats, lard is high in calories, so it should be consumed in moderation.

Cooking with Vegetable Shortening

Vegetable shortening is an incredibly versatile ingredient in the kitchen. Its high smoking point makes it suitable for frying, and its ability to create tender textures makes it ideal for baking. When using vegetable shortening in baking, always ensure to measure it correctly to avoid adding excess fat and calories to your pastries. Using too much shortening can result in overly dense, heavy baked goods.

One of the unique benefits of vegetable shortening is its shelf-stability. It does not require refrigeration and can last up to a year in an airtight container, making it a practical choice for those who do not cook or bake regularly. However, because it lacks flavor, it’s often best used in recipes where other ingredients can shine.

Cooking with Lard

Lard has long been cherished in traditional cooking for its unique flavor and ability to enhance the taste of various dishes. When cooking with lard, it’s essential to choose high-quality, rendered lard-free from additives or preservatives. Look for lard that is minimally processed to ensure you’re getting the most natural and flavorful product.

Lard excels in frying with its high smoke point, offering a savory taste that makes foods crispy and golden. It’s also great for baking flaky pastries like pie crusts and biscuits, as its solid state blends well into doughs, yielding a tender product. While lard has a distinct taste not for every dish, it can enhance recipes with richness and flavor when used judiciously.

Trans Fats and Other Ingredients

Trans fats are man-made fats known to cause health problems, like a higher risk of heart disease. Older versions of vegetable shortening contain trans fats because of the hydrogenation process. Thankfully, many brands have updated their products to be trans-fat-free. To make a healthier choice, check the label and go for a brand that clearly says ‘trans-fat free.’

In addition to fat, vegetable shortening may contain other ingredients such as emulsifiers, stabilizers, and antioxidants. These additives help improve the texture, shelf life, and overall quality of the shortening. While these ingredients are generally recognized as safe for consumption, some individuals may prefer to opt for more natural alternatives without additives.

Lard is predominantly composed of saturated fats, with smaller amounts of monounsaturated and polyunsaturated fats. The fat composition of lard contributes to its unique flavor and cooking properties. However, it’s important to consume lard in moderation due to its high-calorie content.

Nutritional Value and Calories

When it comes to nutritional value, both vegetable shortening and lard are primary sources of fat. Vegetable shortening contains no carbohydrates, protein, vitamins, or minerals. On the other hand, lard does provide some essential nutrients such as vitamin D.

Due to their high fat content, both vegetable shortening and lard are calorie-dense. A tablespoon (12 grams) of Crisco All-Vegetable Shortening contains 110 calories, while the calorie content of lard is similar. It’s crucial to be mindful of portion sizes and incorporate these fats into a balanced diet to avoid excessive calorie intake.

Health Considerations and Diet Options

Both vegetable shortening and lard can fit into a healthy diet if used sparingly, but it’s important to account for personal dietary needs and choices. People with dietary limits or health concerns should select fats that suit their requirements. Plant-based dieters might choose vegetable shortening, and those wanting less processed fat may lean towards lard.

If you’re looking for healthier alternatives to vegetable shortening and lard in baking, there are several options to consider. Butter, coconut oil, and avocado oil can all be used as substitutes, each offering its unique flavors and health benefits. It’s always a good idea to experiment with different fats to find the one that best suits your taste preferences and dietary goals.